Jack Black Under Fire: Tenacious D Fans Demand Apology to Kyle Gass

Jack Black is under growing scrutiny from Tenacious D fans who are urging him to apologize to bandmate Kyle Gass. The criticism follows the band’s recent Instagram announcement and stems from Black’s decision to place Tenacious D on hiatus after remarks Gass made during a live performance. The controversy has now spilled into the comments on the band’s post promoting their upcoming project, “Tenacious D Complete Masterworks Vol. 3.”

“KA-POW! ‘VIDEO GAMES!’ Live at the O2 Arena — on YouTube now! But that’s just a taste — pre-order The Complete Masterworks Vol. 3 and get a full blast of the D!” the band wrote in their announcement.

While the post was meant to generate excitement, fan responses highlighted frustration with Black’s actions.

“Jack should really apologize to Kyle,” one fan wrote. “From a band that has always been political it’s sad that you broke it off for a comment that I’m pretty sure you would’ve made years ago.”

Others have gone as far as calling for boycotts and reconciliation between the duo. “Don’t buy anything until they’re back together!!” one person commented. Another added: “You threw Kyle under a bus, Jack. But, you should make amends. The world is a better place with you both together.”

These reactions underscore the deep rift felt by fans in light of Black’s decision to halt the band’s activities. The controversy coincides with what is set to be one of Tenacious D’s most ambitious releases. Complete Masterworks Vol. 3 will provide an extensive look at the band’s work during a defining stage of their career.

According to Soap Central, the collection will arrive on October 3, 2025, and includes a full recording of the June 16, 2023, O2 Arena concert in London from the Spicy Meatball Tour. The performance showcased Tenacious D at their peak, with setlist highlights including “Tribute,” “The Metal,” and “Beelzeboss (The Final Showdown).”

The Music Universe noted that the release offers more than just the live show. Fans will also get the band’s animated film Post Apocalypto, several music videos such as “…Baby One More Time” and “Wicked Game,” plus a mini-poster — making it a comprehensive collector’s package.

The O2 Arena concert itself was a sold-out success that emphasized the duo’s dynamic chemistry and trademark energy. As confirmed by the band’s official site, the recording reflects Tenacious D at the height of their creative powers during one of their most memorable performances.

Despite the tension between Black and Gass, the upcoming release serves as a reminder of their artistic legacy. For fans, this contrast makes their calls for reconciliation all the more heartfelt, as they celebrate the band’s achievements while facing uncertainty about its future.